What the Chancellor could (and should) have said

George Osborne's problems may have been avoided by a different approach to speech writing. His announcement that he is withdrawing child benefit from the better off was worthy but poorly expressed. This is what he could have said instead:

One of the central planks of Conservative thinking is self-reliance. It is also one of the qualities that made this nation great in the past, and it is one of the qualities we stand in danger of losing. Fortunately, it has not died as yet.

Let me tell you about Sarah Robertson. Sarah and her three children were abandoned by her husband, who left them with huge debts that he could not face. She could have carried on living as before, increasing her debt, she could have gone bankrupt, she could have relied on the State to bail her out. Instead, she decided to do none of those things.

She gave up her comfortable life style, she started a small business, she took her children out of their expensive schools, and she made arrangements to pay back the debt, a little at a time. She is still doing so. She is paying for a debt she did not create, but she doesn't feel sorry for herself, and she knows that she can resume her comfortable middle class lifestyle at some point in the future.

Sarah Robertson is a symbol of the state this country is in, and we need to follow her example.
When we came to power in May, we found the cupboard bare, except for a pile of IOUs. We saw that Britain was, and is, in serious trouble. The previous government have left us with debts so huge that it would cost every man, woman and child £XXX,000 to repay. We have to pay it back. We cannot go bust, we cannot be like Greece and expect the EU to bail us out.

Every one of us has to share in the recovery. Will you do it? Will you share in the pain? Will you join with me in a programme that not only gets us out of the debt but which will get us back among the leading economies of the world? I'm going to ask you to accept some changes, to make some contributions that will hurt.

We will have to cut State spending. We will have to reduce State benefits. But the guiding principle will be this: we will help those who need help, and we will ask those who do not need help from the State to forgo the benefits you do not need. I know it will not be pleasant, I know you will feel you are paying for a debt you did not create, but there is no other way.

We are a party and a government that believes in self reliance. Like Sarah Robertson, we will take charge of our lives, and we will pay back the debt. That's what I am asking you to help me with. Will you do it?

Phillip (0845 165 9240)